Explore the Allure of a Converted Gothic Revival Church in the Berkshires

Discover the Enchanting Candy-Blue Cottage on Martha's Vineyard

Update Experience Whimsy in the Heart of Martha’s Vineyard If the thought of owning a charming cottage resembling a gingerbread house has danced through your mind while strolling through Oak Bluffs, this is your moment. Tucked away at 17 John Wesley Avenue, this Victorian Gothic cottage blends beach-town vibes with storybook aesthetics, offering a unique living experience that integrates history and modern comfort. A Glimpse into Architectural Charm Originally built in 1930, this year-round residence represents the next generation of gingerbread houses, drawing inspiration from the quintessential Victorian Carpenter Gothic style. Its pastel exterior, complete with a gabled roof and inviting wraparound porch, is not just visually appealing; it embodies a rich narrative woven with the history of the Massachusetts coastline. The cottage has seen thriving rental demand, making it a lucrative investment—rentals here can command up to $5,000 a week during peak seasons. A Cozy Inside That Welcomes You With Open Arms Step inside, and the enchantment continues. Investors and homeseekers alike will appreciate the thoughtful design choices—an open-plan layout that features a spacious kitchen, living room, and dining area, creating a communal space perfect for gatherings. Stained glass windows punctuate the space, alongside intricate woodwork that pays homage to its 19th-century origins. The second floor boasts three light-filled bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite complete with vaulted ceilings and a private balcony, ideal for star-gazing at the end of the day. Location, Location, Location 17 John Wesley Avenue is well-situated in the sought-after East Chop neighborhood, putting you steps away from downtown conveniences, the serene Jetty Beach, and the scenic Oak Bluffs Harbor. This property strikes a balance between being a full-time home and a charming summer retreat or Airbnb rental. Your Dream Property Awaits For anyone dreaming of the perfect combination of whimsy and functionality in their next property, this candy-blue cottage could be the answer. It encapsulates the quintessential Martha's Vineyard experience while providing comfortable living year-round. Don’t miss out on this enchanting opportunity! For more details, connect with Kyle Neyer at Tea Lane Associates.